Should You Choose a College Based on Rankings?

June 23, 2025

Jarad Stolz, CLTC, CRPC

Should You Choose a College Based on Rankings?

College rankings are everywhere—magazines, websites, even search engine results. It’s tempting to use them as a shortcut when narrowing down your college list. But here’s the truth: rankings often mislead more than they inform.

Should You Choose a College Based on Rankings?

Most ranking systems rely on metrics that have little to do with your child’s experience or success. Factors like alumni donations, endowment size, or faculty publishing may boost a school’s rank but say nothing about affordability, academic fit, or campus culture. And none of them account for what you will pay after financial aid.

Families who chase rankings can end up choosing overpriced schools, overlooking hidden gems that offer better financial packages, stronger academic support, and a better overall fit.

At Diversified College Planning, we help families look past the hype. Instead of focusing on rank, we focus on:

Net cost after aid
Graduation rates and support services
Strength in your student’s intended major
Post-graduation outcomes

A top-ranked school is only the right school if it’s right for your student—academically, socially, and financially.

Contact us today or set up your FREE consultation:
📅 Jarad’s Calendar
📞 770-662-8510

FAQs: Should You Choose a College Based on Rankings?

Do rankings reflect the best college for every student?

No. Rankings average many factors that may not match your priorities (major strength, cost, support, outcomes). The “best” college is the one that fits your goals and budget.

What do most rankings actually measure?

Inputs like selectivity, test scores, faculty resources, alumni giving, and peer reputation—less about program-level outcomes, four-year completion in your major, or net price for your family.

Can rankings help at all?

They’re a rough starting list or a way to discover schools. Use them as one data point—not a decision rule.

What matters more than overall rank?

Program strength in your major, internships and co-ops, graduation rates, licensure/pass rates (if applicable), career outcomes, advising, and total four-year net cost.

How can ranking-driven choices raise costs?

Prestige schools may offer limited merit, have higher living costs, or stricter renewal rules. Families can overpay when they ignore net cost and outcomes.

Are program/department rankings more useful?

Often. Department-level quality, labs/studios, employer recruiting, and course sequencing affect your day-to-day education and ROI more than an overall number.

What questions should we ask beyond rank?

“What’s the four-year grad rate in my major? Who recruits here? What’s the average time-to-degree? How strong is internship placement? What will we actually pay for four years?”

Does test-optional change how we use rankings?

Yes. As inputs change, rank volatility increases. Focus on stable indicators you can control: academic fit, support, affordability, outcomes.

How should we compare similarly ranked schools?

Build a scorecard: net price (4-year), major outcomes, internship pipelines, class sizes, advising access, housing/travel costs, and graduation probabilities.

What’s a smarter process than “top-rank first”?

Define goals and budget guardrails → shortlist programs with strong outcomes → run Net Price Calculators → visit/engage departments → compare four-year net cost and ROI.

How does Diversified College Planning approach rankings?

We treat rankings as context only. We center fit, affordability, and outcomes by major—so you choose a college that delivers value, not just a number.

Join over 30,000 satisfied clients who trust us to help them achieve their goals!

jarad@dibcompanies.com

mike@dibcompanies.com

© Diversified College Planning. All Rights Reserved. | Designed by Apis Productions